Garmin gets it Wrong!: February 14 2025

I have been using my old wrist base garmin fenix 3 heart rate monitor for a few months now as a way to make sure I do not overdo my easy runs. It took a while to get used to the slower centurion pace plod. Quite often, I thought my garmin must be wrong, but usually, on closer checking of the data, it was probably right, and it was just taking longer than I was hoping for my body and legs to adapt.

They reckon that wrist based heart rate monitoring is not very accurate, but I think it is more than good enough for what I want. Just some general indication to back up the way I am feeling as I have just been so used to pushing through any discomfort in the past.

I suppose it is all about understanding how the garmin works that helps interpret how much attention I need to pay to it.

I have always known that the wrist based HR monitor did not work very well while swimming back in my triathlon days, everyone who had a chest strap. So it should not have come as such a surprise when my garmin went a bit haywire in the very hot, humid weather that was making me sweat profusely. It might have been raining and / or me swimming.

Either way, my garmin recorded me running very slowly in zone 5 and decided I needed 4 days to recover. Lol. As it was an easy run I stopped 3 times during the run and measured my heart rate manually just to make sure there was nothing wrong with me and each time I checked it at between 60 to 100 not the 165 plus that it was saying.

It was a bit disappointing to have garmin drop my VO2 max score from 46 all the way down to 39 but I will keep using the garmin wrist monitor as a guide and hopefully it will be back up again as soon as I knock out a faster parkrun time.



This report was published via Actifit app (Android | iOS). Check out the original version here on actifit.io


13/02/2025
44527
Home Improvement, Jogging, Walking, Weight Lifting, Yard Work

0.02884838 BEE
5 comments

60 instead of 165 is a pretty huge difference. I would have been checking and double checking too! !LOL

0.00027647 BEE

I don't know if it's the Garmin or me but I often (not always) get about 5-10 minutes into a run and it goes mental for about 2-3 minutes, like 160-180 BPM all of a sudden and then back down to 130/40/50 or whatever it was just before that.

I'm pretty sure it's the device, it's like it just decides to go iffy for a little while for no apparent reason.

0.00027019 BEE

Interesting, I suppose it is all about connection between the the 3 green dots on the watch and the skin on the wrist. A good guide but annoying when it stuffs up a prefect graphic.

0.00068115 BEE

Hi. I switched from a chest strap to an arm band. I use the COROS Heart Rate Monitor Strap now and it's more comfortable than the chest strap and hopefully just as accurate according to the tests.

0.00022976 BEE

@wahacoce, is that a strap that goes around the upper arm?

0.00027880 BEE

Yes. It's also used by top trail runners. 🙂

0.00022415 BEE

An arm band would be nice! maybe one day I will up grade.

0E-8 BEE

Congrats on providing Proof of Activity via your Actifit report!

You have been rewarded 586.368 AFIT tokens for your effort in reaching 44527 activity, as well as your user rank and report quality!
You also received a 2.45% upvote via @actifit account.


Rewards Details

The following splinterland boosts were applied to your post:
  • 149 Common Cards Boost: +5 AFIT
  • 128 Rare Cards Boost: +10 AFIT
  • 49 Epic Cards Boost: +15 AFIT
  • 33 Legendary Cards Boost: +20 AFIT
    The following boosts were applied to your post:
    Friend Ranker - L1
    + 1 User Rank
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    Friend Ranker - L2
    + 1.5 User Rank
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    Friend Ranker - L3
    + 2 User Rank
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    Friend Ranker - L4
    + 2.5 User Rank
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    Friend Ranker - L5
    + 3 User Rank
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    Double Raindeer - L1
    + 100 % AFIT
    Friend Boost - L4
    + 16 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    + 12 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    Friend Boost - L4
    + 16 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @browery
    + 12 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @browery
    Friend Boost - L5
    + 18 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @browery
    + 14 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @browery
    Friend Boost - L1
    + 10 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    Friend Boost - L2
    + 12 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    + 5 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    Friend Boost - L3
    + 15 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    + 10 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    Friend Boost - L5
    + 18 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    + 14 % AFIT
    Thanks to your friend @pero82
    Water Bottle - L4
    + 35 AFIT
    Water Bottle - L1
    + 5 AFIT
    Running Shoes - L1
    + 10 AFIT
    Water Bottle - L2
    + 10 AFIT
    Running Shoes - L2
    + 15 AFIT
    Water Bottle - L3
    + 20 AFIT
    Running Shoes - L3
    + 20 AFIT
    ... and 3 other gadgets.
    Boosts increased your AFIT earnings by 514.6080 AFIT
    AFIT rewards and upvotes are based on your: - User rank: which depends on your delegated HP, accumulated AFIT tokens, rewarded post count, recent rewarded activity and owned AFITX. - Post score: which depends on your activity count, post content, post upvotes, quality comments, moderator review and user rank.

    To improve your user rank, delegate more, pile up more AFIT and AFITX tokens, and post more.
    To improve your post score, get to the max activity count, work on improving your post content, improve your user rank, engage with the community to get more upvotes and quality comments.

  • 0E-8 BEE

    !HBIT

    0.00000000 BEE

    Success! @new.things(2/1) You mined .9 🟧 HBIT and the user you replied to received .1 HBIT on your behalf. You can receive 100% of the HBIT by replying to one of your own posts or comments. When you mine HBIT, you're also playing the Wusang: Isle of Blaq game. 🏴‍☠️

    Sorry, but you didn't find a bonus treasure token today. Try again tomorrow...they're out there! You can see your random number generated in the Discord server, #hbit-wusang-log channel. | tools | wallet | discord | community | daily <><

    There is a treasure chest of bitcoin sats hidden in the game. Someone will find it. Happy hunting. 😃

    Check for bonus treasure tokens by entering your username at a block explorer explorer A, explorer B, or take a look at your wallet. Read about Hivebits (HBIT) or read the story of Wusang: Isle of Blaq

    0.00000000 BEE