The Question of Honesty vs. Authenticity

The expression "being true to yourself" is one that we have all heard of. Our early years are spent instilling values such as embracing oneself, marching to the beat of your own drum, and not letting other people change who you truly are. Additionally, such counsel is quite wise and valuable. Self-worth, fulfillment, and happiness all greatly depend on you knowing and valuing who you are and having the guts to live true to who you are.

Source

---

---

However, I believe that there are instances when the emphasis placed by society on extreme self-acceptance might be overdone. Because while defying social pressure to fit in might be beneficial, honesty is an equally important trait that sometimes gets overlooked.

You see, staying "true to your authentic self" shouldn't be an excuse for you to act erratically, lie, or neglect the facts and the truth. You still need to be grounded in reality and show consideration for others in your sentiments, beliefs, and self-expression. And this is where the more potent concept of honesty enters the picture.

---

---

The Importance of Honesty

On a fundamental level, honesty is what allows society and relationships to function with any semblance of trust and cooperation. If we couldn't rely on truthfulness from one another, everything would descend into selfish, chaotic anarchy. We'd never know what to believe, who to believe, or be able to make informed decisions about...well, anything. A lack of honesty corrodes all personal bonds and any sense of accountability.

But setting aside that doomsday scenario, honesty is valuable for so many more reasons:

1. It promotes open communication and understanding. By being honest, you allow for true knowledge and clarity in your interactions, rather than operating based on falsehoods or limited perspectives.

2. It lets you own your mistakes and grow from them. Honesty gives you the opportunity to take responsibility, learn, and improve yourself. Dishonesty just leaves you stuck and stagnant.

3. It earns you respect and trust. People can sense authenticity, but they'll appreciate and value you far more for being a person of integrity who doesn't lie to them.

4. It aligns your words with reality. Honesty means living in truth, which is the only way to make sense of the world as it really is. Delusion may be comforting, but it ultimately fails you.

---

---

The Limits of "Authenticity"

Now, don't get me wrong - authenticity is great. You should be comfortable and accepting of who you are. You shouldn't pretend to be someone you're not just to fit in.

But authenticity disconnected from honesty means your "true self" is hopelessly self-absorbed and narcissistic. It gives you a pass to believe your own personal reality over observable facts. It excuses you from having to defend your views with reason, evidence, or consideration of others' perspectives.

For example, I may "authentically" believe I have uniquely brilliant insights, or that I'm exceptionally talented, or that my ethical views are unassailably correct. But if I'm being dishonest with myself about my limits, blind spots, or flaws in my logic, then my "authentic" self is really just an exercise in arrogant self-delusion.

Or perhaps my "authentic self" makes me want to lie, cheat, or take advantage of others for my own benefit. Well, that's not admirable authenticity - that's just being a selfish jerk.

True authenticity has to be coupled with rigorous honesty - about your capabilities, your misconceptions, your selfishness, your everything. It's not always pretty, but it's the only way to really know yourself and steer yourself toward ethical, productive growth.

Bringing It All Together

Look, I'm not saying you have to brutally rip apart your sense of self or walking around konstantsely berating yourself. Having genuine self-esteem and self-assurance is crucial too. I'm just arguing that to be your "best self," you need to prioritize honesty over an unbridled ego stroking version of "authenticity."

Be radically honest and self-aware about your talents AND flaws. Stay true to your ethical core values, but be open to having them respectfully challenged. Confidently express your identity, but be willing to change your perspectives when faced with new information.

Breathe deeply,look inward, and own all that you authentically are - just make sure honesty is the wellspring from which yousee that authentic self. Because in the end, what good is comfort in delusion? True freedom is found in having the courageous humility to embrace reality, warts and all.

_{Topic inspired by the weekend engagement community}

---

---