ATF compared to Dhedge

Hello everyone if you clicked on this post you are or a ATF holder or a Dhedge holder or a passive income lover. First of all i will make comparaison of the revenue you can get from ATF and Dhedge. The two token aren't really comparable since ATF is 8 month old and Dhedge is way older.

And for the people who doesn't know ATF :

ATF is an passive income token. Payouts are made on a weekly basis. The following tokens are payed out : SIM, ATF, ONEUP, DEC, MEME, CENT, POB.
Each of the ATF holders can get passive income backed by the resource capacity of @valentin86 @smallboost @hive-152804 @archives-upfunds
ATF payout rates :

Now the calculation part : in a week i got 4,7SIM, 1,86ONEUP, 3,4DEC, 1,75MEME, 1,85CENT, 0,25POB, 0,03ATF for holding 50,5 ATF that mean that the apr i'm gonna find will only be valide for the class "Regular".
Current sell price for 50,5 ATF ~= 4,09HIVE
Total value of the coin got in a week : 0,0016 + 0,00045 + 0,0056 + 0,00026 + 0,0092 + 0,0051 + 0,0024 ~= 0,02301
52 x 0,02301 = 1,19652 (without counting the auto compounding due to ATF token in the payout)
That mean that for buying 4 hive of ATF in the end of the year you have way more than 5,2 Hive (if the price stay the same) that's +20% apr.
That is way more than the average apr of dhedge that is ~11.29982%
(source : https://ecency.com/leofinance/@discohedge/dhedge-daily-report-2023-02-11-expected-total-drips-apr-11-29982-at-0-08998900-hivedhedge-20230211t150920z#@dhedge/re-dhedge-daily-report-2023-02-11-expected-total-drips-apr-11-29982-at-0-08998900-hivedhedge-20230211t150920z-20230211t210246z) the 11.29% doesn't doesn't count the small upvote you can get for holding dhedge but you can't have them if you don't hold at least 100 dhedge (in the average) and they aren't big enough to make the apr reach 25%.
To conclude ATF is a really good passive income token at the moment with +20% apr (the apr for higher lever is higher) but the real thing that need to be watched is the evolution of the payout. I mean it's cool to give 900% apr for 3 days but it's better to give 1% that can be compounded for 10 year. And this is why ATF and dhedge CAN'T be compared but if we still do it then we can see that ATF give a better apr at least at the moment. Rember to dyor (do your own research)
For the 0.1 people still reading this post, i hope you enjoyed it and it made you discover a new token, didn't make you suffer to much with my bad writing. See you soon (or not) for next post.