Topcomment weekly curation report (week 31)


image.png

News

There is not a lot of news to share with you. I'm still on holiday, but this week I do have a good internet connection to create and publish the report.
Keep on engaging!

What is Topcomment?

The Topcomment curation service rewards meaningful and engaging comments on the Hive platform. It is manually curated by @topcomment to prevent abuse.
Comments that show effort, substantively engage with the content are eligible for upvotes. The initiative relies on nominations, where users can mention @topcomment to suggest quality comments.

Read all about it in the following blog (also in Spanish!):
https://peakd.com/comments/@topcomment/topcomment-curation-service-info

Read more about the service and how you can support this project below the report!

Weekly Report

To provide transparency I'm generating a list of all comments that were upvoted by @topcomment in the past week.
In the past 7 days Topcomment distributed 88 upvotes to the following commenters:

AuthorCommentTimestamp
@zero49https://peakd.com/@zero49/re-jeandrilespe-szxhxlJul 25 2025 01:28AM
@nachomolina2https://peakd.com/@nachomolina2/szxbu1Jul 25 2025 01:41AM
@liveofdallahttps://peakd.com/@liveofdalla/re-aliento-szxb59Jul 25 2025 01:42AM
@palabras1https://peakd.com/@palabras1/re-aliento-2025724t121437878zJul 25 2025 01:43AM
@jesuslnrshttps://peakd.com/@jesuslnrs/re-inibless-szx8epJul 25 2025 01:45AM
@marlenyaraguahttps://peakd.com/@marlenyaragua/szx6neJul 25 2025 01:45AM
@tonyeshttps://peakd.com/@tonyes/re-roadstories-2025724t162928831zJul 25 2025 01:46AM
@satirohttps://peakd.com/@satiro/re-rosahermosa-szxce3Jul 25 2025 01:48AM
@ackzahttps://peakd.com/@ackza/szwwwfJul 25 2025 01:49AM
@gtghttps://peakd.com/@gtg/re-andablackwidow-1753306770657Jul 25 2025 01:50AM
@soldierofdreamshttps://peakd.com/@soldierofdreams/re-livinguktaiwan-szwyqvJul 25 2025 01:51AM
@elbuhitohttps://peakd.com/@elbuhito/re-edwardstobia-szxdgaJul 25 2025 01:54AM
@patif2025https://peakd.com/@patif2025/re-maiasun84-2025725t125415976zJul 25 2025 05:04PM
@beelzaelhttps://peakd.com/@beelzael/re-bozz-szys5kJul 25 2025 05:13PM
@urrirruhttps://peakd.com/@urrirru/re-riverflows-2025725t19302649zJul 25 2025 05:18PM
@gregscloudhttps://peakd.com/@gregscloud/re-happy080-2025725t122139600zJul 25 2025 05:20PM
@mandysmoonhttps://peakd.com/@mandysmoon/re-jethsaly-szyonkJul 25 2025 05:20PM
@mairene1https://peakd.com/@mairene1/re-jethsaly-szyol2Jul 25 2025 05:21PM
@ericvancewaltonhttps://peakd.com/@ericvancewalton/szyp5bJul 25 2025 05:21PM
@amigoponchttps://peakd.com/@amigoponc/re-maylink-2025725t111133565zJul 25 2025 05:22PM
@cjlugohttps://peakd.com/@cjlugo/re-syberia-szzfj6Jul 26 2025 02:10AM
@sayuryhttps://peakd.com/@sayury/szzh1dJul 26 2025 02:10AM
@syllemhttps://peakd.com/@syllem/re-getheenspring-2025725t201430230zJul 26 2025 02:11AM
@getheenspringhttps://peakd.com/@getheenspring/re-evelynchacin-szz97bJul 26 2025 02:12AM
@luzscarllet18https://peakd.com/@luzscarllet18/re-evelynchacin-szzdqvJul 26 2025 02:13AM
@jluferhttps://peakd.com/@jlufer/szyemaJul 26 2025 02:14AM
@bigorna1https://peakd.com/@bigorna1/re-duvinca-2025726t1045912zJul 26 2025 11:16AM
@nanixxxhttps://peakd.com/@nanixxx/re-enraizar-t00aw7Jul 26 2025 02:36PM
@hiventhusiasthttps://peakd.com/@hiventhusiast/re-nhaji01-2025726t143820156zJul 26 2025 02:47PM
@papilloncharityhttps://peakd.com/@papilloncharity/re-lizelle-2025726t1585919zJul 26 2025 02:49PM
@heartbeatonhivehttps://peakd.com/@heartbeatonhive/re-tydynrain-t00d4bJul 26 2025 02:51PM
@miprimerconcursohttps://peakd.com/@miprimerconcurso/t00iwjJul 26 2025 05:24PM
@vvodjiuhttps://peakd.com/@vvodjiu/re-wanderelle-t00g5eJul 26 2025 05:24PM
@yuraimatchttps://peakd.com/@yuraimatc/re-maylink-2025726t103337406zJul 26 2025 05:25PM
@fernanbloghttps://peakd.com/@fernanblog/re-musicandreview-2025726t16555768zJul 27 2025 02:00AM
@tesmoforiahttps://peakd.com/@tesmoforia/re-eugelys-t01b3iJul 27 2025 02:01AM
@mamaemigrantehttps://peakd.com/@mamaemigrante/re-numa26-2025726t221859616zJul 27 2025 02:01AM
@lanzjoseghttps://peakd.com/@lanzjoseg/t019ukJul 27 2025 02:01AM
@javierariascbbhttps://peakd.com/@javierariascbb/re-nameless16-2025726t204119843zJul 27 2025 02:02AM
@avdesinghttps://peakd.com/@avdesing/re-justclickindiva-t01w26Jul 27 2025 03:08PM
@ikigaidesignhttps://peakd.com/@ikigaidesign/re-ancnoticias-t02bmwJul 27 2025 03:12PM
@thejedohttps://peakd.com/@thejedo/re-galenkp-t02abdJul 27 2025 03:14PM
@beelzaelhttps://peakd.com/@beelzael/re-galenkp-t02ck8Jul 27 2025 03:16PM
@relf87https://peakd.com/@relf87/re-galenkp-t02bddJul 27 2025 03:17PM
@eduardo900613https://peakd.com/@eduardo900613/re-fernanblog-2025727t95510982zJul 27 2025 03:17PM
@ljfenixhttps://peakd.com/@ljfenix/re-fernanblog-t013fnJul 27 2025 03:18PM
@zekepicklemanhttps://peakd.com/@zekepickleman/re-papilloncharity-2025727t94957438zJul 27 2025 03:19PM
@rlathuleriehttps://peakd.com/@rlathulerie/re-floreudys79-2025727t864118zJul 27 2025 03:21PM
@luchylhttps://peakd.com/@luchyl/re-josediccus-2025728t12059185zJul 28 2025 04:50AM
@promete0szhttps://peakd.com/@promete0sz/re-deraaa-t03a25Jul 28 2025 04:51AM
@yecierhttps://peakd.com/@yecier/re-cumanauta-2025728t7439660zJul 28 2025 12:48PM
@sadiel0102https://peakd.com/@sadiel0102/re-fermionico-2025727t12939670zJul 28 2025 12:49PM
@emiliopinosport2https://peakd.com/@emiliopinosport2/t02nz9Jul 28 2025 12:49PM
@tonyeshttps://peakd.com/@tonyes/re-fermionico-2025728t62734435zJul 28 2025 12:49PM
@holoz0rhttps://peakd.com/@holoz0r/re-honeydue-t03t5bJul 28 2025 12:50PM
@jessuses1381https://peakd.com/@jessuses1381/re-veneciabia-t03us0Jul 28 2025 12:51PM
@arc7icwolfhttps://peakd.com/@arc7icwolf/re-harbiter-t03uxpJul 28 2025 12:52PM
@palomap3https://peakd.com/@palomap3/re-harveyword-t03smyJul 28 2025 12:53PM
@marabuzalhttps://peakd.com/@marabuzal/re-yuraimatc-2025727t131652337zJul 28 2025 12:55PM
@numa26https://peakd.com/@numa26/re-palabras1-t031iqJul 28 2025 12:56PM
@felixmarranzhttps://peakd.com/@felixmarranz/re-palabras1-2025727t162219935zJul 28 2025 12:56PM
@whoisjohnhttps://peakd.com/@whoisjohn/re-giathebao-t03ctoJul 28 2025 12:58PM
@keychainhttps://peakd.com/@keychain/re-peaksnaps-t042d4Jul 28 2025 01:21PM
@keychainhttps://peakd.com/@keychain/re-peaksnaps-t042d4Jul 28 2025 01:22PM
@alfazmalek02https://peakd.com/@alfazmalek02/re-bhattg-2025729t105117766zJul 29 2025 09:56AM
@minismallholdinghttps://peakd.com/@minismallholding/re-lizelle-t05iqjJul 29 2025 09:57AM
@repayme4568https://peakd.com/@repayme4568/re-samminator-2025729t85659545zJul 29 2025 10:13AM
@deraaahttps://peakd.com/@deraaa/re-tengolotodo-2025729t92324875zJul 29 2025 10:14AM
@milaanhttps://peakd.com/@milaan/re-sanjeevm-2025729t12445235zJul 29 2025 10:15AM
@holoz0rhttps://peakd.com/@holoz0r/re-ankapolo-t05ta2Jul 29 2025 03:20PM
@marabuzalhttps://peakd.com/@marabuzal/re-psicologopoeta-2025728t20251624zJul 29 2025 03:21PM
@robibasahttps://peakd.com/@robibasa/re-sissim72-2025729t222847816zJul 29 2025 09:08PM
@janavedahttps://peakd.com/@janaveda/t06hs6Jul 29 2025 09:10PM
@nexus0https://peakd.com/@nexus0/re-papilloncharity-t06dbzJul 29 2025 09:14PM
@queenmeteorhttps://peakd.com/@queenmeteor/t06apcJul 29 2025 09:16PM
@heartbeatonhivehttps://peakd.com/@heartbeatonhive/re-achim03-t06draJul 29 2025 09:19PM
@slothlydoesithttps://peakd.com/@slothlydoesit/re-achim03-t064dhJul 29 2025 09:20PM
@tonyeshttps://peakd.com/@tonyes/re-roadstories-2025729t214237739zJul 30 2025 01:42AM
@psicologopoetahttps://peakd.com/@psicologopoeta/re-roadstories-2025729t21501938zJul 30 2025 09:19AM
@bleujayhttps://peakd.com/@bleujay/re-zekepickleman-t07uv8Jul 30 2025 05:03PM
@namikshttps://peakd.com/@namiks/re-macchiata-t07vmkJul 30 2025 05:06PM
@yeleisma2023https://peakd.com/@yeleisma2023/re-yuraimatc-2025730t0122440zJul 30 2025 05:25PM
@valued-customerhttps://peakd.com/@valued-customer/re-builderofcastles-t07z2yJul 30 2025 05:26PM
@emlynxhttps://peakd.com/@emlynx/re-samostically-2025730t1749112zJul 30 2025 05:28PM
@mdrguezhttps://peakd.com/@mdrguez/re-erikah-t081duJul 30 2025 05:28PM
@bruno-kemahttps://peakd.com/@bruno-kema/re-justfavour-t07z2lJul 30 2025 05:29PM
@jesuslnrshttps://peakd.com/@jesuslnrs/re-carrinm-t0808hJul 30 2025 05:30PM
@riverflowshttps://peakd.com/@riverflows/re-holoz0r-t07kxmJul 30 2025 05:31PM
@holoz0rhttps://peakd.com/@holoz0r/re-riverflows-t078vwJul 30 2025 05:31PM
@nancybriti1https://peakd.com/@nancybriti1/t08j2aJul 31 2025 01:43AM
@cajirohttps://peakd.com/@cajiro/re-charjaim-t08mfeJul 31 2025 01:43AM
@emiliorioshttps://peakd.com/@emiliorios/re-abelarte-t08mesJul 31 2025 01:44AM
@palabras1https://peakd.com/@palabras1/re-ancnoticias-t08kf2Jul 31 2025 01:44AM
@netflixrhttps://peakd.com/@netflixr/re-mrarhat-t08ku5Jul 31 2025 01:45AM
@beelzaelhttps://peakd.com/@beelzael/re-macchiata-t0a7zhJul 31 2025 10:13PM

Alltime totals

I've started the Topcomment curation initiative on december 16, 2024.
The total number of upvoted comments since the startup is: 2657

The following table show the Hivers that have been upvoted the most.
You can see the number of upvotes in total, the change in ranking compared to last week and the increased number of comments since last week.

#CommenterUpvoted comments
1@ph110237
2@avdesing37
3@nanixxx34
4@tonyes34
5@palomap332
6@promete0sz25
7@fernanblog24
8@holoz0r24
9@enraizar23
10@shine671223
11@manclar22
12@felixmarranz21
13@elbuhito21
14@cmplxty20
15@syllem20
16@justclickindiva18
17@agmoore18
18@jesuslnrs18
19@jlufer16
20@zekepickleman16


Thanks everyone for engaging!

If you want to have a mention when you are on this list or want to be mentioned in every weekly update post from @topcomment, just let me know in the comment section!

Which comments can get upvotes and which don't?

Which comments are eligible for upvotes and which are not?
Not all nominated comments will receive an upvote from Topcomment. While the concept of "quality" is subjective, there are a few key factors I consider when deciding whether to upvote a comment. Additionally, there are certain reasons why even a well-written comment might not be upvoted.

Here are the current guidelines:

Do's

1. Put effort in the comment
Be sure you have put some effort in creating a longer comment. There is no exact number, but a comment that is just a few words long won't get upvoted.

2. React to the content of the blog
The comment should be a thoughtful response to the blog post. It must engage with the content and provide meaningful interaction with the author’s ideas. It shouldn't be a reply telling your own story.

No upvotes for

1. Comments with hate speech, racism, conspiracy theories or other negative reactions
I strive to keep the community positive. Comments promoting hatred, racism, or conspiracy theories will not be upvoted.

2. Comments from users with Hivewatchers downvotes
I do not want to support scammers or fraudulent activity. If a user has been downvoted by Hivewatchers, I will not upvote their comment.

3. AI-generated comments
These comments will not receive upvotes, as they are not authentic human interactions.

4. Comments that already have significant rewards
If a comment has already received a substantial reward, I will skip the upvote. The same applies to comments that are part of the commentrewarder initiative.

5. Giveaways or contest entries
There are some initiatives asking you to submit your entry in the comments. These are excluded from Topcomment upvotes.

6. Commenting on own blogs
Comments from bloggers on their own blog will not be upvoted. It is only natural that you respond to comments on your own blog.

Support Topcomment with Delegations

The more delegations Topcomment gets, the higher the rewards we can give away!
And you profit from the delegation as well since we return 80% of the curation rewards to the delegator.
The rewards are sent in the form of liquid Hive on a daily basis. So, supporting Topcomment with a delegation can be really beneficial for you.

You can use the following tool to delegate an amount of your choice or select one of the predefined amounts below.

https://thecrazygm.com/hivetools/account/delegate/topcomment/100

| 10 HP | 25 HP | 50 HP | 100 HP | 250 HP | 500 HP | 1000 HP | 1500 HP | 2000 HP |

Follow the Curation Trail

If you don't want to delegate you can also choose to following the Topcomment voting trail via Hive.Vote.
This way you do support the project and the commenters, but you'll receive the curation rewards yourself. In Hive.Vote you can configure a percentage for the votes.
https://hive.vote/dash.php?trail=topcomment&i=1

Upvote and Reblog

You could help the @topcomment project by upvoting and reblogging this post. The more people know about this initiative, the more it will stimulate engagement on Hive ❤️
The post rewards will be used to support the project!

Mentions

When you are in the top 20 most upvoted Hivers, you get a mention, If you don't want to be mentioned when you are in that list, just leave me a comment.

If you want to get a mention even though you are not in the list, you can also leave me a comment and I'll add you to the following mention list:
@emeka4, @shine6712

Start using Topcomment!

What are you waiting for? Start using this service by mentioning @topcomment in replies to valuable comments.

If you have any comments or questions; feel free to comment on this post or contact me on Discord.
You can find me in the Topcomment Discord Channel


image.png


Kind regards,

@friendlymoose@roadstories@lauramica@incublus
image.pngimage.pngimage.pngimage.png
0.02118623 BEE
18 comments

What I don't like about services that put links is that they explicitly assume Hive frontend even if that's not needed, instead of using front-end agnostic links. I even complained about WorldMapPin about the same.

Please use front-end agnostic links whenever possible.

For example, here you point to my comment by using this:
@gtg https://peakd.com/@gtg/re-andablackwidow-1753306770657

Using markdown that would be [@gtg's comment](https://peakd.com/@gtg/re-andablackwidow-1753306770657) which is OK and would work, except it will force viewers to use that particular frontend, and if viewer is using ecency.com, hive.blog or whatever other front-end they will most likely be annoyed by that fact and want to get back to the original site they were browsing.

Proper way to link content is to provide frone-end agnostic links that in this case would look like this: @gtg's comment

code: [@gtg's comment](/@gtg/re-andablackwidow-1753306770657)

(i.e. just strip domain part and start from /, frontends are expected to follow that scheme and point you to proper content no matter what dapp you are using.

0.00005500 BEE

I've been around for quite some time, bit I didn't know this!
I will certainly try this out!
Thanks for explaining this!

0.00000000 BEE

Woohoo I made it to the list! Thanks!

0.00000000 BEE

Thanks for support

0.00000000 BEE

Hello dear friends @topcomment, good morning

Thank you very much for the great support and the mention

Congratulations to the top-voted authors

Have a great weekend everyone

0.00000000 BEE
(edited)

Thank you very much my friend, I will continue to do my best to comment.

0.00000000 BEE

Thank you very much for your continued support and mentions, and thank you for this great and important project that encourages people to make quality comments. Thank you!🤗

0.00000000 BEE

Thanks for continuing to run this, even while you're on holiday!

0.00000000 BEE

👍

0.00000000 BEE

Thank you for your support.

Best regards.

0.00000000 BEE

Gracias.
Thank you for your support.
Best regards.

0.00000000 BEE

Thank you so much for your great job! 😘

0.00000000 BEE

Thank you very much for your support! 🖤

0.00000000 BEE

I love commenting for its engagement and networking with this great community. It is the real connection between us and it is nice to see comments organically rewarded a little extra!

0.00000000 BEE

Thank you so much for valuing the comments in this way. It's important that they were taken into account for curating. Thanks to the curators and organizers: @topcomment😍

0.00000000 BEE

Thanks for the mention and support @topcomment

0.00000000 BEE

I am delighted to be on this list. Thank you for this important initiative, for the effort you put in and for supporting us.
Have a great day.

0.00000000 BEE

Thank you for your work and support. ❤️🤗

0.00000000 BEE

Thank you so much for the kind mention. It is appreciated!

0.00000000 BEE

I pray to the Almighty God that you will join us again after the holidays. We are all grateful to you for giving us great ideas about delegation information and comment upvote replay along with top comments and information. I hope you spend your valuable time well with good internet, thank you sir.

@topcomment sir I always appreciate your hard work thank you sir.

Best regard @mdakash62

0.00000000 BEE

Thanks!

0.00011839 BEE

You are always be most welcome sir

0.00000000 BEE