
We cannot burn our way out of the HBD crisis.
The HBD crisis is the result of the ratio of HBD market capitalization to the HIVE capitalization. If this rises over 30%; it will trigger the HBD haircut.
I am not sure exactly what the hair cut does, but I don't like hair cuts and want to avoid it.
The site HBD Stats tracks the HBD/HIVE ratio. As I write, it shows the percent at 29.96% ... gulp.
I personally think that raising the interest on HBD to 20% was one of the worst financial decisions that I have ever seen. I have studied monetary theory for decades. HBD is a derivative of HIVE. As a derivative, HBD functions like debt. Taking on a huge debt load was guaranteed to cost the HIVE blockchain severely.
HBDstats proves the interest rate was foolish. This time last year, the HBD market capitalization hit $11.5 million. It has since fallen to 8,688,220. 11.5m - 8.6m + INTEREST is over 3 million. This last year we've seen over three million HBD converted to HIVE. The average price was something like $0.05.
3 million HBD converted to HIVE generated something like 60 million HIVE.
The market simply cannot absorb the HIVE generated by the HBD conversions.
We are still paying 10% on HBD savings ... compounded monthy. There is $6,266,052 in HBD savings. We will pay over $626,605 in interest on this (I didn't calculate in the compounding). We need to convert at least this much HBD to HIVE to avoid the haircut. To cover the interest on HBD, we need to generate about 18 million HIVE.
We cannot burn ourselves out of this crater.
Downvoting the people we don't like will not save us from this crater either. Downvoting just shifts who gets the reward.
The only way out of the crater is to convert HBD to HIVE and to power up the HIVE.
To do my part, I bought 15 HIVE and powered up. That's all I got. It is a drop compared to the millions generated from the HBD interest.
I don't think that there's enough chumps in the world to recover from the HBD mistake.
Reducing the interest rate might help. You can go to your witnesses page and pull your vote from witnesses voting for 10% or higher and vote for active witnesses under 10%. The ideal interest is zero, but that is a different discussion.
Holy cow, it looks like @gtg just dropped his vote from 10% to 8%. The ideal is zero, but anything point taken off the interest rate helps.
I generated an image on night cafe of fire coming out of a fire hose for this post.
I liked the image so much that I decided to mint it as an nft on Meme HIVE. I am selling 4 editions of the #meme for 280 MEME (that's a third of a penny). This covers the cost of minting the NFT.
We can't burn our way out of the HBD crisis. The crisis is about the ratio of HBD to HIVE. Burning HIVE only makes the problem worse. I bought and staked 15 HIVE. The HBD crisis is generating HIVE by the tens of millions.
Dropping the interest rate would help ... the ideal rate is zero percent. The final image is a screen shot from HBDstats.com which shows the ratio as it approaches 30%.
